[Carpenter] Mystic Plains Wind Energy

[Justin Johnson]

I believe that the US FWS has found endangered bats breeding in the area, so this looks to me mostly to be a play to get the county, through tax breaks, to pay for any mitigation costs.  I would be interested in hearing about the current state of the bat question, Kelly.
 
It is interesting to me how county councils will give away just about anything to attract new development.  I've read a book that said that Cabelas has profited more from avoiding taxes than from actual sales since they switched from a catalog company to a huge store model.  Remember that the wind energy companies are worried that the federal tax incentive for wind energy may not be renewed, so they are feeling around for what other goodies they can get. 

Justin Johnson
Missouri Prairie Foundation
Executive Director
573-356-7828
www.moprairie.org

--- On Mon, 6/16/08, wayne morton <wayne2946 at yahoo.com> wrote:

From: wayne morton <wayne2946 at yahoo.com>
Subject: Re: Mystic Plains Wind Energy
To: "Ted Cooper" <ted at tswllc.com>, "Steve Mowry" <stevem4444 at aol.com>, "Steve Heying" <ashlandbrdman at yahoo.com>, "Mike Currier" <Mike.Currier at dnr.mo.gov>, "Linda Tossing" <Ltossing at aol.com>, "Kelly Srigley-Werner" <Kelly_SrigleyWerner at fws.gov>, "John Burk" <jburknwtf at ktis.net>, "Jim Wildman" <jwildman at tnc.org>, "George Seek" <seekg at grm.net>, "Denny Donnell" <hddonnell at hotmail.com>, "David Erickson" <David.Erickson at mdc.mo.gov>, "Andrew Forbes" <andrew.forbes at mdc.mo.gov>, "Alan Leary" <alan.leary at modot.mo.gov>, "Amy Buechler" <abuechler at confedmo.org>, "Susan Hazelwood" <hazelwoods at mchsi.com>, "Charley Burwick" <burwick.charles at sbcglobal.net>, "Justin Johnson" <missouriprairie at yahoo.com>, "Bill White" <bill.white at mdc.mo.gov>, "Dave Murphy" <dmurphy at confedmo.org>, "John Hoskins" <john.hoskins at mdc.mo.gov>, "Carpenter Prairie in the Mystic
 Plains COA" <carpenter at mysticplains.org>, "Frank Oberle" <foberle at nemr.net>
Date: Monday, June 16, 2008, 3:33 AM






Hi Frank,   This is scary. If they use the ridge tops the chickens also use [as I understand they plan to do] this could mean the end of prairie chickens in the Mystic area. Also considerable damage to bats and probably migratory and other birds. Can any of our organizations or MDC do anything about this?   Wayne

--- On Sat, 6/14/08, Frank Oberle <foberle at nemr.net> wrote:

From: Frank Oberle <foberle at nemr.net>
Subject: Mystic Plains Wind Energy
To: "Wayne Morton" <wayne2946 at yahoo.com>, "Ted Cooper" <ted at tswllc.com>, "Steve Mowry" <stevem4444 at aol.com>, "Steve Heying" <ashlandbrdman at yahoo.com>, "Mike Currier" <Mike.Currier at dnr.mo.gov>, "Linda Tossing" <Ltossing at aol.com>, "Kelly Srigley-Werner" <Kelly_SrigleyWerner at fws.gov>, "John Burk" <jburknwtf at ktis.net>, "Jim Wildman" <jwildman at tnc.org>, "George Seek" <seekg at grm.net>, "Denny Donnell" <hddonnell at hotmail.com>, "David Erickson" <David.Erickson at mdc.mo.gov>, "Andrew Forbes" <andrew.forbes at mdc.mo.gov>, "Alan Leary" <alan.leary at modot.mo.gov>, "Amy Buechler" <abuechler at confedmo.org>, "Susan Hazelwood" <hazelwoods at mchsi.com>, "Charley Burwick" <burwick.charles at sbcglobal.net>, "Justin Johnson" <missouriprairie at yahoo.com>, "Bill White" <bill.white at mdc.mo.gov>, "Dave Murphy" <dmurphy at confedmo.org>, "John Hoskins"
 <john.hoskins at mdc.mo.gov>, "Carpenter Prairie in the Mystic Plains COA" <carpenter at mysticplains.org>
Date: Saturday, June 14, 2008, 2:12 PM


 



 


 



Contact Us  •  Program Schedule  •  Our Team  •  Advertise With Us  •  DTV Answers


HOME
NEWS

SPORTS

WEATHER

COMMUNITY

DIRECTORY

ENTERTAINMENT
RSS Feeds
Home > News : Story 
Search KTVO3Web

     




Local 
State
Nation/World 
Crime
Health


Special Features 
Elections 2008
Business and Technology
Entertainment News
Fact Finder
"Pump Prices" form
Recalled Items
Strange News


ADVERTISEMENT








Sullivan Co. wind project hinges on tax breaks



 
By Dana Jay
Posted: Friday, June 13, 2008 at 12:14 p.m.
MILAN, MO. -- Landowners in Sullivan and Adair Counties stand to make a lot of money if Tradewind Energy decides to go ahead with the Shuteye Creek Wind Project and build wind turbines on their land.

However, the company won't build if it doesn't win a contract with Ameren UE, and the development manager says they can’t win the contract without some big tax breaks.

Wednesday the Sullivan County Commission held a meeting to discuss just how many tax incentives it wants to give the company.  Some elected officials were torn between bringing in the new business and giving away the tax base.

According to Tradewind Energy development manager Rod Northway the company would pay approximately 60 landowners between $800 thousand and $1.6 million in royalties by the time the project is complete.

One landowner tells us her family stands to receive about $6,750 dollars per turbine the company builds on their property.

That money will come back to the county eventually, says Presiding Commissioner Chris May.

“Typically farmers spend their money, and it circulates pretty quickly, and we look at that as an advantage,” May said.

Northway adds that the project would also create up to twelve new jobs and up to 600,000 payroll dollars.

Despite the payments to landowners and new jobs, some elected officials and community members expressed concern that the commission would give Tradewind too many tax breaks.

"I would like to see the whole county benefit, not just a small portion of the county," Sullivan County resident Culley Cowgill told KTVO after the meeting.

That sentiment is echoed by County Clerk Mike Hepler, who notes that Tradewind’s competitor is paying twice as much to a neighboring county.

“If this project was sitting in Gentry County and was assessed and taxed in the same manner it would be coming in at almost six million dollars per year in local property tax,” Hepler said.  He’s proposed that Tradewind pay Sullivan County $2.7 million per year.

“I’m not against [the project] in any way, shape or form.  I am against giving away the tax base,” he said.  In his opinion that’s what would happen if Tradewind paid any less.

“Every time you give away tax, you cost [the county] money, services or combination of both,” Hepler said.  He says he’s concerned about the county’s return on investment.

But the presiding commissioner is confident that offering big tax breaks is better than offering no tax breaks and driving the company away. 

"We hope that at the end of the day, we have some type of agreement that a substantial amount of money is coming in that at least would prevent anyone from having to raise a levy," Mays said.

The wind in Sullivan County could create renewable energy for years to come, but the opportunity to bring turbines to the Heartland is not open ended.

May hopes a committee of representatives from several taxing districts including the townships where turbines would be located, the library, the hospital, and others will reach a consensus on how much the county is willing to offer in the next couple of weeks.

“There's a sense of urgency, so we would hope that in two months or so we'll come to a conclusion on what [we’ll offer,]" May said.

Tradewind representatives hope the county will come to a conclusion sooner or later.

Wind energy is renewable; the demand for it is finite.  Missouri utilities are only obliged by law to purchase a set amount of wind power.   So, if Tradewind does not win a contract with Ameren UE as it hopes, it could miss out on the opportunity to sell the wind energy altogether. 

Tradewind also plans to build turbines in Adair County.  Representatives have yet to meet with commissioners regarding tax breaks, but a Northway says he plans to do so in the near future.







Share this: 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Comments 
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them; they are not reflective of the views or opinions of Barrington Broadcasting, KTVO3, its directors or employees. 
If you believe a comment violates the Barrington Terms of Use, please report it here. 
Submit a comment about this story 

Nuclear Anyone?
Wind energy is a pipe dream. A fleeting disaster of a plan for alternative energy. We should be building more nuclear reactors, it is the cleanest, safest, and most efficient form of energy production that we know of today. Giving this company huge tax breaks is like a slap in the face to every taxpayer in Missouri. Government subsidies are EVIL.
— Tony P, Kirksville






Latest News 



VideoStories 




ADVERTISEMENT










SPONSORED LINKS





 




SPONSORED CONTENT











 
About Us | Contact Us | Advertise With Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use 



      
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://www.seaplace.org/pipermail/carpenter/attachments/20080616/518dcc57/attachment-0001.htm